skip to main content
CALL US: New York (646) 530-8420
CALL US: New Jersey (609) 454-8520

Facebook icon for Princeton Admissions CounselorsShare   Twitter icon for Princeton Admissions CounselorsTweet This   Mail icon for Princeton Admissions CounselorsEmail This

How To Choose Your College Application Essay Topic

Posted: 8/29/2015 10:45:26 AM by Benjamin Caldarelli | with 0 comments

College Admissions CounselingEureka, Rosebud, Cheesecake? A great idea for a college admission essay.

I saw her eyes light up as she said it and there was no turning back. Rima (not her real name) was brilliant, no doubt about it, and she had the grades and test scores to back it up. An aspiring physician, she kept up a Herculean schedule of activities, internships and community activism outside of school. She was an ideal candidate for a variety of selective pre-med programs, but she knew that while she was a star at home, she would have to compete with many just like her throughout the country. To say the least, she was nervous. She wanted me package her up just right so college admissions committees would want her.

I diligently helped her brainstorm ideas for a winning personal statement. We discussed people who were important to her (her dad, Marie Curie), books she read that inspired her (Rushdie’s Midnight’s Children), experiences that had influenced her (her brother had been born prematurely) and what and how she had learned from all of them. The possibilities were rich, but before proceeding, I asked her how her friends and parents would describe her. After a bit of equivocation we invited her mom to join the conversation.

When the question was put directly to Rima’s “Mum,” her response was clear. Rima’s tenacity was fierce and always had been. Rima had been too humble to say herself just how fierce, so I asked her Mom to tell us stories from her early childhood on up to the present. A more entertaining time I cannot remember. We had so much fun laughing and crying at the most moving stories. The best were instances of Rima’s desire to experiment on her own body, throwing herself in to walls and other objects to feel and understand how her body worked, what caused pain and pleasure and why.

Related: 4 Keys to an Ivy League Application Essay

“Yeah, but is the committee really interested in stuff from my childhood?” Rima questioned. A valid point, so I asked Mum what the most recent examples of Rima’s tenacity were. And then it happened, she hesitated, as if it was silly and unimportant, but then said, you should have seen her Cheesecake last Thanksgiving. “Really,” I said, “do tell me about it Rima, I love cheesecake.”

Mum and I both witnessed the passion, as Rima explained her trials and tribulations of making this cheesecake that was a replica of the “original” made by Hippocrates, the Greek doctor. As she spoke about when, how, and why she became interested in making the magisterial cake for her family, it was clear to all three of us that while this seemed like an unorthodox topic for a college admission essay, it would showcase her in a way that was unique, authentic and genuinely interesting.

All writing is collaborative, and as a writing teacher and coach I always try to facilitate the process in order for each individual to best realize their potential. That the three of us had a wonderful afternoon was no accident. I have faith in the writing process as a good in itself. We may influence others, to get a spot in a college, a job or even in matters of the heart, but when we try to express ourselves in writing we always learn, about ourselves and our world.  And Rima was admitted to her 3 top choice colleges. Cheesecake indeed!  

Princeton College Consulting  is a New Jersey based educational consulting firm providing concierge college admissions assistance. For a Free 30 minute consultation, Call Peter Tilles at 609-454-8520 or e-mail He will be happy to talk more about how to write great application essays and all the other aspects of the college admissions process. 
Sign up for The Savyy Applicant, our montly newsletter, to receive more college admission information, advice, and special offers. Topics include: how to write great college essays, prepare for a college interview, use Social Media to your advantage and much more.
Whats's your College Admissions Index? Use Our Free Calculator to Gauge Your Chances of Admission to Specific Colleges.

Image result for calculate results images 


Blog post currently doesn't have any comments.

Our Firm

Princeton College Consulting is a New Jersey based educational consulting firm providing college admissions counseling and athletic recruiting services to local, national and international students.

Our Mission

To maximize the probability of students and student athletes earning admission and scholarships to top choice colleges while minimizing stress and anxiety.

Contact Info

252 Nassau St
Princeton, NJ 08542
(609) 454-8520

590 Madison Ave., Suite 2100
New York, NY 10022
(646) 530-8420


Copyright © 2015 Princeton College Consulting. All Rights Reserved.
None of the Trademark holders are affiliated with Princeton College Consulting, LLC.